Customer Rating: 
Summary: Simply Put: An Amazing Movie
Comment: Paul Schrader has crafted a unique movie viewing experience. Using a combination of styles, he renders a psychological biography of one of the most fascinating and enigmatic personalities in the history of Japan. Schrader goes directly to the source and acts out Mishima's own words in the form of narration and enacting scenes from Mishima's novels. Adding to this, he acts out Mishima's final day when Mishma committed seppuku as a political protest. He also makes heavy use of flashbacks to tell Mishima's lifestory. This three layered storytelling would be ambitious enough in any form but Schrader further layers it by making each of the three novel scenes bold and different from each other.
Each of the three novel scenes has a unique color scheme. Schrader is bold and unsparing in using Mishima's own words to display his mental and emotional turmoil as he struggles to exhibit and explain both his homosexuality and his sadomasochism. Mishima was acutely aware of his own body. He thought he was weak and inferior and he overcompensated with bodybuilding and militarism. Macho guy-bonding activities. Mishima was a bundle of contradictions. A true individual who supported the return of Imperialism. A man who was so exhibitionist, he sought to display himself and his life as a work of art.
I can't really do the movie justice here. You just have to see it. It really is fascinating, imaginative and intensely thought provoking. Watch it in conjunction with Mishima's psychologically autobiographical short film, Patriotism. Then move on to his writing. Rarely has one person fascinated me so much and made me think and feel on so many different levels.
Customer Rating: 
Summary: An artistic biography
Comment: This review is for the Criterion Collection DVD edition of the film.
Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters is a work of art. Depicting the life of Yukio Mishima, a controversial Japanese writer, who was considered for the Nobel Prize, this film delivers.
The film depicts the last hours of Mishima's life with flashbacks of his earlier days.
While the film is an American production, it is in the Japanese language. The film was too controversial to be released on home video in Japan, but has aired on television there. I thought is well made and especially so because of the score by Philip Glass which I think is a masterpiece. I have been a fan of his music for many years. The film has beautiful indoor sets and cinematography also.
As the film is based on the life of an actual person, I will skip the usual plot summary.
This release is far better than the earlier DVD release of the film and loaded with supplements.
Disc 1 contains the film with optional director's and producer's commentary, a theatrical trailer and the option of having the voice-over narration in Japanese or English
Disc 2 has a BBC documentary on Mishima, video interviews with John Bailey, Tom Luddy Mata Yamamoto, Philip Glass, Eiko Ishioka, Mishima biographer John Nathan, and Donald Richie, an audio interview with Chieko Schrader, and an archival video interview of Mishima himself.
This is the best edition of the film to get and I highly recommend it.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Elegance & Brutality
Comment: Finally Criterion has gotten around to including one of my all time favorite films, Mishima. Directed by Paul Schrader and with beautiful set pieces by Ishioka Eiko, this is a truly great bio pic which Criterion has generoursly upgraded. This is the only bio pic I can think of that's based on a major modern Japanese author. It would be interesting to see other directors make films about Kawabata, Tanizaki, and Kafu. In Mishima you see his final day before committing seppuku as just another day and filmed in color. Then you switch to black and white shots of Mishima's childhood. Finally, there are the richly stylized set pieces that showcase Mishima's novels. Schrader does a great job of switching between these three separate time frames and you can see the influneces of Bresson, Dreyer, and Ozu. I won't go into the story details but once you start watching its hard to look away from Ogata Ken's intense protrayal.
The real treat for me was the special features, which are by themselves worth buying this edition for. There's an excellent 55-minute documentary by the BBC called The Strange Case of Mishima Yukio where you can see Donald Keene discuss the problems of translating Mishima's writing into English. It was great seeing Keene speaking when I'm so used to reading his books and various translated works.
Also, there is a great interview with Donald Richie and John Nathan who both knew Mishima and visited him in Tokyo. John Nathan wrote the excellent biography on Mishima (another good one is Mishima Into The Void by Marguerite Yourcenar.) A good interview with Chieko Schrader, who helped write the script and is the wife of Paul's brother, Leonard.
Also video interview with composer Philip Glass, set designer Ishioka, and the producers that show how much work and effort go into creating a film on such a grand scale.
Overall, its a very entertaining and informative look at a great modern writer, Japanese or otherwise, and is highly recommened to anyone interested in writing and Japanese culture.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Mishima: life and fiction
Comment: Mishima: A Life in Four Chapters is visually stunning and features a soundtrack by Phillip Glass. It's about the life of writer Yukio Mishima, and the film alternates between his last day - when he and his private army(!) of ultra-nationalists tried to take control of the japanese army and reinstall the emperor as ruler of Japan - earlier episodes (as a boy, teenager and so on), and filmed scenes from his novels. All in all, we get some insights of Mishimas way to self-realisation, as a writer and warrior, or something like that. The "past" is filmed in b/w, the "present" in color and the novels in very strong color shemes. Past, present and fiction is thus weaved together which actually works very well.
The transfer is remarkable as usual with Criterion, and the extras are overwhelming. Also, the case of the DVD is almost too much with metallic finish, strong colors and fold-out design. Five stars to Criterion for caring about movies and giving us films like this!
Customer Rating:
Summary: Extraordinary does not even begin to describe how great Schrader's film is....
Comment: If someone said "I'm going to pitch a film about Yukio Mishima, a writer well known in Japan but only known to intellectuals here in America, to a Hollywood studio, get Francis Ford Coppola and George Lucas to help me get it made, make it entirely in Japanese (except for some narration), and make it about the inner workings of the artist, not a straighforward biography", most would say that that person should be committed. Well, that's pretty much what Paul Schrader did, and he succeeded wildly beyond all expectations. Not only is this film one of the greatest biographies ever made, it really captures the essence of Mishima brilliantly. Yukio Mishima is a man that the term "complicated individual" was invented for. He was a poet, playwright, essayist, short story writer, novelist (which he is best known for), filmmaker (he made one film, Patriotism, which is now on DVD), body builder, Japanese patriot, believer in the Bushido code, and nationalist. He also committed suicide attempting (fruitlessly) to convince the Japanese army to restore Japan to the emperor. Instead of doing a straightforward biography, Paul Schrader gets inside of Mishima, and shows the immense complexity and genius that was his and his alone. The only film that I really compare this film to (just in technique and attitude) is Sergie Paradjanov's The Color of Pomegranates, which was about the Armerian poet Sayat Nova. That film isn't a straightforward biography, but a complex, esoteric film about the inner workings of the artist, much like this one. These two films couldn't be more different aesthetically, but they are almost identical in their approaches.
If Schrader made a decent film, you could say "well, he got the film made. It wasn't perfect, but that's OK. He tried to make something artistic". But that isn't the case. Not only did Schrader make this film with American financing, he made what is arguably his best film. Schrader is very erratic at times, doing great work (he wrote Taxi Driver), making decent films (Auto Focus), and making mediocre films (Hardcore and the lousy remake of Cat People). In this film, he's made his masterpiece. Everything works here, from the amazing cinematography to the brilliant score of Philip Glass (it's one of Glass's best scores, and that's saying something). This really is a remarkable piece of work.
|
